Current Thanksgiving Availability

(updated Friday PM 11/21)

We are no longer accepting new Thanksgiving orders by phone or email.
Walk-ins / in-person only please.

This close to the holiday, availability on Thanksgiving centerpiece items is… super frothy! As such, we can no longer take preorders in advance or hold items over the phone. It’s an in-store, first-come, first-served situation from here on out. We strongly encourage you to visit the shop in person, or text us at (718) 569-8426 with questions. We can’t hold inventory over text, but we can at least give you up-to-the-minute info on stock.

Whole Turkeys & Turkey Parts

  • Under 15 LBs: 🚫 SOLD OUT THROUGH HOLIDAY

  • 15 - 20 LBs: ⏱️ Currently sold out. Restocking Saturday 11/22 PM

  • 20+ LBs: ⏱️ Currently sold out. Restocking Saturday 11/22 PM

  • Turkey Breast: ⏱️ Currently sold out. Restocking Saturday 11/22 PM

  • Turkey Leg Quarters: ⏱️ Currently sold out. Restocking Saturday 11/22 PM

  • Wings & Offal: ⏱️ Currently sold out. Restocking Saturday 11/22 PM

Porchetta & House-Smoked Ham

  • Hams (all sizes): 🚫 SOLD OUT THROUGH HOLIDAY

  • Porchetta: ⏱️ Currently sold out. Restocking Saturday 11/22 AM

Duck & Chicken

  • Whole Duck: 🟡 Available, but limited

  • Duck Breast: 🟡 Available, but limited

  • Duck Leg Quarters: 🟡 Available, but limited

  • Duck Confit: 🔴 Sold out, hoping to restock over the weekend

  • Whole Chicken: 🟢 Good availability through the holiday

  • Chicken Breast: 🟢 Good availability through the holiday

  • Chicken Leg Quarters: 🟢 Good availability through the holiday

Beef Cuts

  • Beef Tenderloin: 🚫 SOLD OUT THROUGH HOLIDAY

  • Standing Rib Roast: 🟢 Good availability through the holiday on fresh; limited on dry-aged.

  • Boneless Strip Roast: 🔴 Limited availability on fresh; sold-out on dry-aged.

  • Assorted Beef Steaks: 🟢 Good availability on a wide range of smaller steaks and cuts through the holiday.

Lamb Cuts

  • Rack of Lamb: 🟡 Good availability at the moment; expect to sell out by Thanksgiving

  • Lamb Shoulder: 🟢 Good availability through the holiday

  • Lamb Leg: 🟢 Good availability through the holiday

Other Common Questions:

  • I need a turkey and I forgot to preorder! Can you help?

Don’t worry, it happens to the best of us. We always order a few extra birds to have on hand just in case. However, these will be available in-store only, on a strictly first-come first-served basis. They cannot be reserved online or over the phone. We will post the latest turkey size and availability info above… there is no need to call.

  • I forgot to preorder, and I want something that isn’t turkey for Thanksgiving.

We’ll do our best <3. We can usually accommodate the odd standing beef rib roast or porchetta, for example. Please email meat@fostersundry.com to inquire about non-turkey items for Thanksgiving. You can also text the shop or call, but call volume will be high, and you may get a faster response by text or email.

  • When can I pick up my turkey?

Our turkeys are harvested and processed the week before Thanksgiving, and will arrive at the shop around lunchtime on Saturday 11/22. We’ll need a little while to sort and tag them, so if you did not place a preorder, we recommend waiting until Sunday 11/19 to come in for a walk-in bird. Customers who DID place a turkey preorder can pick up on their designated day, or anytime from Sunday 11/23 on.

  • Are you open on Thanksgiving?

We are indeed. We’ll be open from 10AM to 2PM on Thanksgiving Day.

  • How do I even cook this a Thanksgiving turkey anyway?

We’ve written an extensive Turkey Day FAQ to help you figure things out.